NTBCC ordinary meeting: Drummond room at Broughton St Mary’s Church on Bellevue Crescent
Monday 14 August, starting at 7:00pm
-
- Welcome / Introductions / Attendance
- Approval of the minutes of the ordinary NTBCC meeting held on 12th June 2023 (To approve)
- Matters arising from previous minutes (and not included on agenda below) (To discuss)
- Police matters and proposal for improved reporting (To note/discuss)
- Culture and Communities (Convener’s report)
- CEC Culture & Communities Committee held on 10 August 2023
- Edinburgh’s Winter Festivals – update on procurement (To note / discuss)
- Calton Hill – Request to Re-open Nelson Monument (To note)
- Licensing (Convener’s report)
- HMO Best Practice Guide 2023 consultation (closing 10 August) (To note)
- STL Licensing – Council update following the Judicial Review (To note)
- Licensing applications – e.g. 1 Gayfield Square (To discuss)
- Transport (Convener’s report)
- Tram works – handover / Road safety Audit (To note)
- East London Street – petition at 17 August Transport & Environment Committee (To note)
- Picardy Place – compliance with Edinburgh Street Design Guidance (To note / discuss)
- Participation Request vs. less formal discussions with Transport Officials (To note / discuss)
- Planning (Convener’s report)
- 108 -116 & 118 Dundas Street (22/05886/FUL & 22/05884/CON) Further Hearing on 23 August (To note)
- Former Smithies site (23/01201/FUL) – 11 flats (10x 2 bed) as approved (To note)
- Environment (Convener’s report)
- Governance
- Future planning for Office Bearers (To discuss)
- CEC upcoming consultation re. Community councils boundaries / funding etc. (To note / discuss)
- AGM (as agreed to be held on 9 October (In Person) and committee reports)
- Residents’ Open Forum / AOCB
Please note: before or during the meeting, names and email addresses may be recorded. Email addresses are held and used for circulating information about NTBCC but may also be used to seek residents’ views on local issues.
Transport convenor’s report
Tram Works
We met with a Council official who has been assigned to the Trams to Newhaven project to
discuss the significant amount of work yet to be completed Including over 1000 defects
along the route. Formal handover of the project has been delayed until late August to allow
the Contractor more time to complete this work. The Road Safety Audit has been received
by the Council and Contractor and is currently being reviewed by both parties before it is
finalised. Further work may result from this audit.
East London Street
The petition from local residents seeking support for various measures to improve East
London Street in both the short and longer term has received sufficient signatures and will be
considered at the August Transport and Environment Committee meeting. We are working
with local Councillors to ensure that this does result in urgent action to address the concerns
identified by residents and others. NTBCC will be submitting a deputation in support of the
petition.
Picardy Place
Work on the central island at Picardy Place is expected to be complete by the end of August
but we still have not received the requested copy of the drawings despite submitting a
Freedom of Information request. The Council has requested clarification of which
dimensions we are interested in obtaining. This seems to be a deliberate attempt to delay
providing this information. In conjunction with a Spokes representative, we have already
identified one significant non- compliance against ESDG. We understand that this will need
to be rectified
.
Participation Request
We have been holding quarterly meetings with Daisy Narayanan and Ruth White over the
last year as a result of pausing our Participation Request. At our meeting last month, we
raised concerns that the meetings were not delivering the expected benefits in terms of the
active collaboration we had been seeking when the Participation Request was submitted. It
was agreed we would jointly review the meetings with a view to implement changes prior to
the next scheduled meeting in October.
Prepared by Mike Birch
12 August 2023
Environment convenor’s report
No Convener’s report but includes a discussion on the Short-term Working Group ‘Conservation & Adaptation’ project.
Licensing convenor’s report
NTBCC Licensing Report – August 2023
Culture and Communities convenor’s report
The CEC Culture & Communities Committee met on Thursday, 10 August.
Items of interest included:
1. Edinburgh’s Winter Festivals – Update on Procurement (8.1)
This included the specification for procurement of a prime contractor (2.1) and sought approval for a contract of three years, plus two one-year extensions. It was noted that the Council contributes £0.813m to the cost of Edinburgh’s Hogmanay.
There were amendments by the Lib Dems, SNP and Greens. The first, a procedural one designed to tighten up the procurement process, was accepted by the administration, but not the other two. A vote was held to choose between the report (plus Lib Dem amendment) and those of the SNP/Greens, which were regarded as complementary.
Although the administration won by 6 votes to 5, it’s worth noting the losing amendments as they are closely connected with past NTBCC submissions and our work on the ‘Use of Public Spaces for Events and Filming’.
The SNP recommended:
- a “joint venture model” to “enable the Council to work in tandem as an equal partner” with the provider.
- “a programme of events… within the city centre and reaching into fourteen local town centres and communities outwith the city centre”.
- “a review before and after each year with key stakeholders inclusive of the … community councils: Old Town Community Council, West End Community Council, New Town Broughton [sic] Community Council, Tollcross Community Council.”
The Greens recommended:
- “To incorporate current Council strategies related to climate, nature and environment” in the plans and “require annual reporting on the climate, nature and environmental impact of the previous year’s festivals”.
- updates on reduction of diesel generator use.
- adding key performance indicators (KPIs) for water management, renewable energy-powered generators, freight arrangements etc.
- checks that the real living wage (RLW) is being paid. (It was noted that paying the RLW was still not obligatory in the contract.)
- officers to ensure community benefits are real and appropriate.
2. Parks and Openspace [sic] Investment Update (8.2)
The total for Parks in 2023/24 is £4.053m, including an extra £3m approved on 23 February 2023. The allocation includes funds for lighting, accessibility improvements, toilets, “ongoing and new investment”, operational equipment etc . There were 17 beneficiaries including three premier parks. In our area, or right on the edge of it, the Water of Leith received investment — but not Calton Hill, still not included in any investment plans.
3. Closure of The Nelson Monument on Calton Hill (9.1)
Motion By Cllr McFarlane was passed asking for information on repairs and reopening by 5 Oct 2023.
4. Grass Cutting Standards (9.6)
The motion by Cllr Parker (Greens) passed. — for a less intensive approach to grass cutting, consistency with other nature and climate policies on the Nature Network, Biodiversity Action Plan, Thriving Greenspace Strategy, 2030 Climate Strategy and Edinburgh Adapts plan.
5. Regarding ‘Community council scheme and boundary review’
(to be discussed separately under ‘Governance?)
On 10 August 2021, a meeting was held on between the EACC Board and CEC Governance (Gavin King, Laura Miller). This discussed a CC boundary review, anticipating the use of data from the 2022 census (to be published in 2023).
On 1 February 2022, a report entitled ‘Collaborative work with Community Councils’ was presented to the Culture & Communities Committee.
This detailed “current arrangements” and funding and proposed CC elections in 2024, a boundary review in 2023, council support for neighbourhood networks and locality community planning partnerships, support for CCs (largely information and training)
On 28 July (this year), CEC sent out a notice about a ‘Community Council scheme and boundary review – pre-statutory consultation’, (with a followup from EACC on 6 August entitled ‘Community Council Scheme Review’).
This “pre-statutory consultation” involved an in-person meeting on 7 August (which I attended), and future ones on 15 August and 17 August (virtual). Four topics were discussed: boundaries; virtual, hybrid and in-person meetings; the governance scheme; engagement by CCs.
My view of the 7 August meeting, as per my email to the Google Group of 8 August, “CEC provided no explanation of the present boundaries, and did not not suggest any possible criteria for changes, or indeed any basis for the organisation of community councils, leaving the initiative of an unstructured discussion entirely to participants.”
Finally on 11 August, CEC launched a ‘Community Council scheme and boundary review (pre-statutory consultation) questionnaire’(closing on 1 September). This arguably is written more from the Governance section’s point of view than the CCs. Most of the questions are now to do with the Scheme (5 items), rather than to the boundary (1) or funding (0).
Simon Holledge
13 August 2023
Planning convenor’s report
planning report to follow